multi store and network solutions

Ok, I have tried with 3 separate people at network solutions to set up the multi store aliases and they each told me a different way and none of them work. Here's what I did.
I went to store 2 and set up a cname record with an alias named "vital" that points to store 1. So I have vital.store2.com pointing to www.store1.com
Setting up the domain alias from store 1 to store 2 is where network solutions keeps changing their recommendations, do I do that as a CNAME record and point it to vital.store2.com?

Any help is much appreciated, I'm not getting any support from network solutions and I emailed them the page that describes exactly how to do this on nopcommerce. Thanks!

You should not be worried about CNAME, you can setup multi-store easily following ways

You can own two domains like www.store1.com, www.store2.com
Then create two stores in nop (configurataion -> stores) and configure
Store name: store1
Store URL: http://www.store1.com/
HOST values:: www.store1.com,store1.com

Store name: store2
Store URL: http://www.store2.com/
HOST values:: www.store2.com,store2.com

Or

You can own one domain  www.store.com and create a subdomain www.abc.store.com
Then create two stores in nop (configurataion -> stores) and configure
Store name: store
Store URL: http://www.store.com/
HOST values:: www.store.com,store.com

Store name: abc
Store URL: http://www.abc.store.com/
HOST values:: www.abc.store.com,abc.store.com

This is how I have mine set up in NOP:
Store 1
http://subdomain1.domain1.com
Host values - subdomain1.domain1.com

Store 2
http://subdomain2.domain2.com
Host values - subdomain2.domain2.com

I have both bindings on the one site in IIS
subdomain1.domain1.com
subdomain2.domain2.com

With this setup it seems NOP is only showing the subdomain1 site on both domains.
When I move products, whatever is registered to show in the Store 1 is what shows on both domains, even though the URL changes in the URL bar at the top. Also changes to Page Titles and other things point to the Store 1 showing on both domain names.
Yes, I have disabled the check box for Ignore Store Limits in the Catalog settings, as described in documentation.

Is this not the correct way to set it up?

RCC wrote:

Yes, if it's not limited to specific store, item will be shown in both stores by default. Configuration seems correct, I would put one slash(/) end of the store url like http://subdomain2.domain2.com/ to ignore some issues.

I do have the slash after the store URLs
I still can't figure out why when I go to Store 2 I see Store 1 products only.

Moving a product from Store 1 to Store 2 removes it from Store 1 and 2 ..
The same products show in both store no matter what changes I make.

I must have something wrong that I just can't find..

I think I just found it!
Both stores had Display Order set to 0, I changed one and the products seem to be behaving!